MP Seeks Conviction of Monark for Nazi Remarks

Recommended products

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn a commission from purchases made through these links.

The Ministry of Public Prosecution in Sao Paulo (MPSP) has reversed its initial position and is now seeking the conviction of influencer Monark for moral damages, stemming from a 2022 speech defending the existence of a legally recognized Nazi party in Brazil. The case’s prosecution has seen significant changes. In March, prosecutor Marcelo Otavio Camargo Ramos advocated for archiving the case, arguing that Monark’s statements, while misguided, fell under the protection of freedom of conviction and expression. However, in April, Ricardo Manuel Castro replaced Ramos and submitted a new request, urging the judge to disregard the previous plea and sentence Monark to pay R$4 million. MPSP explained in a statement that the position of lead prosecutor is temporarily vacant. Marcelo Ramos was initially designated to fill this role for the latter half of March and April, but the State Attorney General suspended his appointment for April. In a statement released last Wednesday (April 15), the new prosecutor asserted that Monark “expressly defended the creation of a Nazi party and the possibility of declaring oneself anti-Semitic as an exercise of freedom of expression, which it is not.”

Monark’s defense team expressed surprise at MPSP’s reversal, pointing out that Marcelo Ramos was replaced after requesting the case’s dismissal. “At that time, the Public Prosecutor’s Office properly recognized that the accusations against the presenter were based on fragmented readings of his speeches taken out of context,” the defense stated. Monark’s lawyers further maintain that he was expressing his anarchist ideology, which advocates for absolute freedom of expression and association regardless of state intervention. On March 27, an MPSP decree designated Marcelo Ramos as Deputy Justice of Human Rights until April 30. Subsequently, on April 7, a new decree appointed Ricardo Manuel Castro to the position during the first half of April and annulled the prior decision for the second half of the month. MPSP maintains that its members have the independence to act on procedures related to their function, in accordance with the Federal Constitution.

Controversial Fine for Dutch MP’s Offensive Post Compared to Nazis; Civil Suit Filed Against Monark over Nazi Statements

In a separate case, The Hague’s Court of Appeal upheld a €450 fine against Forum for Democratie MP Pepijn van Houwelingen for an offensive post on X in September 2022. The post criticized two government ministers and featured a doctored image placing them next to a Nazi flag. Van Houwelingen initially received a suspended fine, but after appealing, he was required to pay the full amount. Following the initial complaint, he replaced the original post with one featuring a hammer-and-sickle communist flag, which he argued was a more appropriate comparison. These events follow MPSP’s filing in 2024 of a public civil lawsuit requesting Monark pay R$4 million for his controversial statements regarding Nazism.