Skip to content
Players/For/Life
News

Debunking: PS Plus Games Not Actually Getting Worse

Oliveocelot's analysis shows that while some months receive criticism for PlayStation Plus offerings, certain periods like September 2025 boast impressive Metacritic scores, indicating a variety of quality games being provided, but player preferences might influence the perceived decline in quality.

Marcus Thompson · 2 min read

Analyzing PS Plus Games Quality: Metascores Debunk Decline Claims

PlayStation Plus has undergone significant changes recently, but the core benefit remains: subscribers to the basic tier still receive three free games each month. Contrary to recurring complaints within the gaming community, a recent analysis suggests the quality of these games has not declined over time. Canadian YouTuber Oliveocelot investigated this perception by analyzing the Metacritic scores of all games offered on PlayStation Plus over the past four years. He calculated monthly average scores to determine overall trends. Oliveocelot's findings indicate that the perceived decline in quality is unfounded. For example, September 2025, which featured Psychonauts 2, Stardew Valley, and Viewfinder, achieved the highest Metascore of any month in the last four years, likely due to the strong reception of Psychonauts 2. In contrast, August 2025, with Lies of LA, DayZ, and My Hero Ones Justice 2, received the lowest score during the same period, possibly dragged down by DayZ. The three months prior to this analysis showed a strong average Metacritic score above 80, a relatively rare occurrence. Ultimately, Sony cannot cater to every subscriber's taste each month. Consequently, the perceived value of PlayStation Plus offerings will invariably vary from person to person.

In Case You Missed It

In our exploration of gaming trends, Marcus Thompson's analysis in "Oblivion: Remaster is This Year's Most Successful Relaunch" Oblivion: Remaster is This Year's Most Successful Relaunch caught our attention. Diving into Ampere Analysis' study of 42 game relaunches, Thompson reveals fascinating trends between remakes and remasters, with Oblivion: Remaster bucking them impressively, earning $180 million and attracting 7 million monthly players since its April release. Meanwhile, Carlos Mendoza's latest piece on Players for Life transports us to 80s Hill Valley as he shares the upcoming LEGO Speed Champions Time Machine Back to the Future set LEGO Back to the Future DeLorean on its Way. Scheduled for January 1, 2026, this 357-piece set lets you build both versions of the iconic DeLorean, complete with Mr. Fusion energy source and all the iconic features. And speaking of fan favorites, Mendoza also published "FF7 Rebirth Welcomes New Update with Highly Requested Features on PC" FF7 Rebirth Welcomes New Update with Highly Requested Features on PC recently, where he delves into the December 2024 update's improvements and highly requested features.

// The Friday recap

Enjoyed this article? You will like the Friday recap.

Where to buy

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

  • PlayStation, Horizon Forbidden West, 6” Varl Action Figure with 3 Accessories, The Shapes Collection, for PS5 Fans & Collectors Ages 17+

    See the price on Amazon
  • Marvel Legends Series Gamerverse Miles Morales Boricua Suit, Spider-Man 2 Video Game-Inspired Collectible 6 Inch Action Figure

    See the price on Amazon
  • BENGOO G9000 Stereo Gaming Headset for PS4 PC Xbox One PS5 Controller, Noise Cancelling Over Ear Headphones with Mic, LED Light, 7.1 Surround Sound, Soft Memory Earmuffs for Nintendo Xbox Series X|S

    See the price on Amazon
  • No More Heroes 3 – Day 1 Edition - PlayStation 4

    See the price on Amazon
  • PowerA Twin Charging Station for Dualsense Wireless Controllers, Charge, Sony PlayStation, PS5, Officially Licensed

    See the price on Amazon

Read next in News

See all →