Skip to content
Players/For/Life
Movies & TV

Critics and Audience Devastate Season 4 of Netflix's The Witcher

Despite some setbacks in its fourth season, The Witcher is preparing for a final hurrah with its fifth and likely last season, aiming to reconnect with fans who may have felt disappointed but still hold hopes for a satisfying conclusion to Geralt's story.

Carlos Mendoza · 2 min read

Disappointing Scores for Season 4 of The Witcher Amid Casting Change and Complex Storylines

The fourth season of Netflix's The Witcher has received disappointing scores. Critics on Rotten Tomatoes gave it a 53% approval rating, while fans rated it even lower, at 17%. Many viewers attribute this negative reception to Henry Cavill's departure from the role of Geralt of Rivia, now played by Liam Hemsworth. Some feel the show has lost its original appeal because Hemsworth lacks Cavill's unique charisma. The casting change isn't the only source of criticism. Confusing storylines, inconsistent pacing, and a lack of narrative focus have also drawn complaints. Many viewers feel that The Witcher has become overly complex, with drama, action, and fantasy elements competing for prominence. Social media is full of commentary from viewers who feel the show has strayed from its original form. Dissatisfaction with the script and creative direction is widespread. Despite the backlash, Netflix has confirmed a fifth season, which may be the show's last, giving Geralt one more chance to regain favor with fans. The show's magic appears to be fading.

In Case You Missed It

Midway through our chat about Netflix's The Witcher casting shakeups, we thought it'd be fascinating to explore why Liam Hemsworth was chosen to replace Henry Cavill as Geralt. Carlos Mendoza over at Players for Life did just that in his recent article, "Here's Why Liam Hemsworth Was Chosen to Replace Henry Cavill", revealing Lauren Schmidt Hissrich's reasoning behind the recast and how Hemsworth's ability to portray both strength and vulnerability made him perfect for depicting Geralt at his lowest point. If you're curious about the creative rationale behind this change, give Carlos' piece a read here Here's Why Liam Hemsworth Was Chosen to Replace Henry Cavill. But hold onto your gaming hats, because before you dive back into your current session, don't forget to mark next Tuesday on your calendar! Our tech-savvy contributor Sophie Laurent is back with 'Fear The Spotlight', her latest post highlighting the Epic Games Store's free game drop for this week. Published just yesterday, this insightful piece reminds us that every Tuesday brings new opportunities to expand our gaming libraries at no cost. So, why not take a quick break and check out Sophie's article here Don't Forget This Tuesday: Epic Games Store PlayersForLife 'Fear The Spotlight' for Free to ensure you don't miss out on Thursday's release of 'Fear The Spotlight'? In other exciting gaming news, our resident finance whiz Bruno Pferd takes a deep dive into Capcom's latest financial results in his recent article "Capcom Enjoys Another Exceptional Semester, Profit Nearly Doubles as Devil May Cry 5 Surprises", exploring how the company managed to sell over 23 million game units without a major AAA title release, thanks largely to the surprise success of Devil May Cry 5. Check it out for an insightful look into Capcom's strategic wins and future plans here Capcom Enjoys Another Exceptional Semester, Profit Nearly Doubles as Devil May Cry 5 Surprises!

// The Friday recap

Enjoyed this article? You will like the Friday recap.

Series info

Official Name
The Witcher: Blood Origin
Brief Summary
More than a thousand years before the world of The Witcher, seven outcasts in the elven world unite in a blood quest against an unstoppable power.
Released
December 25, 2022
Genre
Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Action & Adventure, Drama
Production Companies
Hivemind, Platige Films, Little Schmidt Productions, Nefarious Purposes
Countries of Origin
US
Actors
Sophia Brown, Laurence O'Fuarain, Mirren Mack, Lenny Henry, Jacob Collins-Levy, Zach Wyatt, Lizzie Annis, Huw Novelli, Francesca Mills, Amy Murray, Minnie Driver, Michelle Yeoh
Producers
Tania Lotia, Sasha Harris
Ratings
6.6/10 (739 reviews)
Number of episodes
4
Number of seasons
1

Where to buy

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

  • McFarlane Toys The Witcher Geralt of Rivia 12 Action Figure (13441-4)

    See the price on Amazon
  • Dark Horse Deluxe The Witcher 3: The Wild Hunt: Geralt Heart of Stone Figure, Multicolor

    See the price on Amazon
  • McFarlane Toys Netflix The Witcher Geralt of Rivia (Season 2) 7 Action Figure with Accessories

    See the price on Amazon
  • McFarlane Toys - The Witcher Ciri & Geralt of Rivia (Season 3) 7in Action Figure 2pk

    See the price on Amazon
  • McFarlane Toys The Witcher Geralt of Rivia (Viper Armor: Teal) 7 Action Figure with Accessories

    See the price on Amazon
  • MEGA The Witcher Building Toys Set, Geralt’s Griffin Hunt with 1170 Pieces, 1 Micro Action Figure and Accessories, Adult Collectible

    See the price on Amazon

Read next in Movies & TV

See all →