Skip to content
Players/For/Life
Community

Fallout: 'It's the Stupidest Thing We've Done,' Bethesda Recounts This Fiasco

Fans are still hoping for a standalone Fallout 5, but the nylon bag controversy in Fallout 76's Collector's Edition has left some with lingering doubts about Bethesda.

Ahmed Hassan · 3 min read

Bethesda's Turbulent Fallout: Navigating Challenges in Post-Apocalyptic Development

Since Bethesda acquired the Fallout license nearly two decades ago, the iconic post-apocalyptic series has faced its share of challenges. These include a recent next-gen patch for Fallout 4 in April 2024, which critics noted for introducing new issues, and the widely panned launch of Fallout 76 in 2018. A veteran from the studio recently discussed these particularly difficult moments in the franchise's history.

Bethesda's Contentious Fallout 76 Launch and Collector's Edition Debacle

In 2018, as fans awaited Fallout 5, Bethesda released Fallout 76. Developed by a smaller team, the game's launch generated significant controversy for the studio. It debuted with numerous bugs and broken features, but this was not the only issue. Further problems arose when the promised canvas bag in the game's Collector's Edition was substituted with a cheaper nylon alternative.

Bethesda's Regretful Fallout 76 Collector's Edition Bag Fiasco and Lessons Learned

Pete Hines, Bethesda's former marketing boss who departed in 2023, recently discussed the Fallout 76 Collector's Edition bag fiasco with DBLTAP. Hines recounted his initial skepticism about including a bag in a $300 Collector's Edition, stating, "When I heard they were sticking a bag in the Collector's Edition and charging 300 for it, I thought, 'What on earth is this?' It felt like a slap in the face." He explained that a canvas shortage emerged, and by the time he became aware, someone had already decided to substitute it with nylon. Reflecting on the situation, Hines admitted, "Looking back, my biggest mistake was not making sure fans got what they wanted, not some poor substitute. It’s safe to say, that’s one of the dumbest things I’ve done at Bethesda." The incident remains a significant talking point, even seven years later, as one of Bethesda's notable missteps. Despite the initial controversy, Fallout 76 has significantly improved through subsequent updates and additional content. However, the incident left some fans wary, and many still hope for a standalone Fallout 5. Moving forward, the expectation is that future projects will reflect lessons learned from this experience.

In Case You Missed It

For all you fans of retro-futuristic gaming narratives and dystopian adventures, Bruno Pferd has unveiled an exciting new project on Players for Life. Published on July 28, "Amazon Prime Video Announces Wolfenstein TV Series, Using the Same Team as Fallout" dives into Amazon's latest venture to adapt the legendary Wolfenstein series into a gripping television show. With the same creative powerhouse behind the upcoming Fallout adaptation, this series promises to deliver an action-packed journey with B.J. Blazkowicz leading the charge against authoritarian regimes and pseudo-scientific threats. Dive into the details at Amazon Prime Video Announces Wolfenstein TV Series, Using the Same Team as Fallout and see what the future holds for this beloved franchise on screen. For all the gaming history buffs out there, make sure to check out Ahmed Hassan's latest dive into the lore of one of our favorite franchises. In his post "Fallout: A Major Revelation Nearly 30 Years Later" (published on August 8, 2025), he uncovers a surprising revelation about Fallout’s origins and its connection to another iconic post-apocalyptic RPG, Wasteland. Discover the twists and turns that led to Fallout's creation and its journey through different publishers over the years. Dive into the full story here Fallout: A Major Revelation Nearly 30 Years Later. Exciting news for fans of intense first-person shooter games and historical alternate realities! Bruno Pferd delves into the upcoming adaptation of the iconic Wolfenstein series on July 25, 2025. From its origins in the early '80s to its recent resurgence with titles like Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus, this franchise has left an indelible mark on gaming culture. Now, under MGM Studios' supervision and with Fallout's Patrick Somerville at the helm, the journey from game to series is set to begin Wolfenstein to be Adapted into Series by Fallout Producer. Dive into the details and speculate on what’s in store for this legendary franchise!

// The Friday recap

Enjoyed this article? You will like the Friday recap.

Game info

Official Name
Fallout 76
Brief Summary
Bethesda Game Studios welcome you to Fallout 76. Twenty-five years after the bombs fall you and your fellow Vault Dwellers, chosen from the nation’s best and brightest, emerge into post-nuclear America on Reclamation Day, 2102. Play solo or join together as you explore, quest, build, and triumph against the wasteland’s greatest threats. Explore a vast wasteland, devastated by nuclear war, in this open-world multiplayer addition to the Fallout story. Experience the largest, most dynamic world ever created in the legendary Fallout universe.
Platforms
PlayStation 4, PC (Microsoft Windows), Xbox One
Released
November 14, 2018
Genre
Shooter, Role-playing (RPG)
Play Modes
Multiplayer, Co-operative, Massively Multiplayer Online (MMO)
Content Rating
19+
Languages
Chinese (Simplified), English, Japanese
Genre
Bethesda Game Studios
Genre
Bethesda Softworks
Ratings
56/100 (259 reviews)

Where to buy

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Read next in Community

See all →