Player Spent a Year Playing Only PS Plus Extra Titles

PS Plus Extra Subscriber Completes 45 Games in a Year, Expresses Dissatisfaction with Limited Catalog Compared to Xbox Game Pass

A PlayStation Plus Extra subscriber, Reddit user narkaputra, undertook a self-imposed challenge: to play only titles available through the service for an entire year. Having returned to video games after a break, they opted for this tier of Sony’s service, paying approximately 144 for the subscription. During this period, narkaputra focused exclusively on single-player campaigns, deliberately avoiding multiplayer-centric games. Over the year, they completed 45 different campaigns, including titles such as Red Dead Redemption and Marvel’s Spider-Man. In total, they earned 1,203 trophies, including two coveted platinum trophies. Despite the high number of games completed, narkaputra expressed dissatisfaction with the PS Plus Extra catalog. They highlighted its limitations when compared to Xbox Game Pass, which continues to stand out for offering major new releases on day one. The PlayStation Plus Extra collection also includes an assortment of classic Ubisoft games (though the specific titles were not mentioned) and frequently adds new titles while removing older ones.

FIST: Forged In Shadow Torch Missing from PS Plus Extra Catalog – Possible SKU Issue?

Regarding content changes, the game FIST: Forged In Shadow Torch has been temporarily removed from the PS Plus Extra catalog. While this could be due to a glitch on the PlayStation Store, Sony has not added it to their “Last Chance to Play” section or officially announced its departure. The game has been missing for several weeks, suggesting an issue with its product listing (SKU). Players who downloaded FIST via PS Plus Extra before its removal can still access it, but new players will not find it in the catalog as the PS Plus Extra tag is currently missing from its store page.

Upcoming Departures from PS Plus Extra and Premium Libraries – Augmenting Debate on Subscription’s Long-Term Value

Looking ahead, several titles are slated to leave the PS Plus Extra and Premium library by August 19, 2025. Among these are The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, Star Wars Jedi: Survivor, the Sword Art Online series, Dreams, Hotel Transylvania: Scary-Tale Adventures, Lawn Mowing Simulator: Landmark Edition, Naruto to Boruto: Shinobi Striker, PJ Masks: Heroes of the Night, Ride 5, Source of Madness, and Realization. Other titles also departing by that date include Song (Premium), Two Point Hospital: JUMBO Edition, Vacation Simulator (VR2) (Premium), Watch Dogs 2, and Wild Hearts. Players should note these dates to avoid missing out. Despite some criticisms, narkaputra described their experience as “the new gaming.” However, this opinion is not universally shared by other users. Many comments on Reddit suggest that, over time, the PS Plus Extra catalog loses its initial impact, particularly once the most critically acclaimed games have been played. For these users, this raises questions about the subscription’s long-term value.

Upcoming PS Plus July 2025 Lineup Reveal – New Titles Including Carmen Sandiego, Dungeons of Hinterberg, and Atomfall

Subscribers can expect the next PS Plus lineup to be revealed in July 2025, with both Extra and Premium tiers anticipated to receive new additions. Based on historical trends where games released approximately a year prior often join the service, titles like Carmen Sandiego, Dungeons of Hinterberg, and Atomfall may make an appearance in the July 2025 lineup. This player’s year-long challenge demonstrates that PlayStation Plus Extra offers sufficient content to keep a dedicated gamer engaged for an extended period. However, it also highlights the service’s limitations, particularly for those who intensely consume the most popular new releases. Sony is reportedly aware of these dynamics and is adjusting its offerings to maintain the service’s competitiveness.

In Case You Missed It

If you’re a PlayStation fan eagerly awaiting the next wave of games to hit your console, be sure to mark your calendar for May 20th! Jonathan Dubinski’s latest post over at Players For Life delves into Sony Interactive Entertainment’s upcoming PlayStation Plus offerings for the month. From the atmospheric “Sand Land” to the intense JRPG experience of “Soul Hackers 2,” and the classic warfare action in “Battlefield V,” there’s something for every gamer this May. Dive deeper into the full lineup and prepare your gaming schedule accordingly—check out PlayStation Plus: Sand Land, Soul Hackers 2, and Battlefield V for May 2025 Games for all the details! If you’re a PlayStation Plus subscriber looking for the latest in free games, be sure to check out “PlayStation Plus: Here’s the List of Free Games for April 2025, Including Hogwarts Legacy…” by Marcus Thompson (April 9, 2025). The post highlights an exciting lineup featuring titles like Hogwarts Legacy and Blue Prince, along with plenty of other games across various genres. Don’t miss out on this month’s offerings—visit the link to see what you can add to your gaming library! For those interested in the surprising success stories of cooperative gaming, be sure to check out Marcus Thompson’s latest piece titled “It Takes Two: 16 Million Copies Sold in Just Three Years, Who Would Have Thought?” (published on March 28, 2024), where he delves into how this game from Hazelight Studios has not only been a critical darling but also a commercial hit. With its innovative gameplay and broad accessibility through various gaming subscriptions, “It Takes Two” continues to captivate players around the world. Dive in for more insights at It Takes Two: 16 Million Copies Sold in Just Three Years, Who Would Have Thought?!