Home NewsCritical Review: Under 12s Will Love It, Others Might Not

Critical Review: Under 12s Will Love It, Others Might Not

by Carlos Mendoza

Key Takeaways

Created with AI - we're still experimenting, so apologies if it misses the mark

  • The urban setting of Lumiose in Pokémon Legends ZA initially offers a nostalgic experience for fans, but technical limitations and outdated graphics detract from the player experience, particularly in urban areas.
  • The open-world format raises questions about whether the trade-offs were worthwhile, with the game feeling artificial and repetitive, even featuring copied and pasted structures.
  • Enthralling nighttime battles and real-time combat enhancements in Pokémon Legends ZA offer a more dynamic and engaging battle experience, emphasizing timing, positioning, and evasion.
  • To fully capitalize on the potential of Pokémon Legends ZA, Game Freak needs to upgrade its tools and graphics engine and refine its approach to creating engaging open-world environments.

Our favorite Goodies

Nostalgic Lumiose Revisit: Urban Pokémon Adventure Faces Diminishing Appeal

Pokémon had a rough few years after shaking things up with their new formula, but the series seems eager to follow the Assassin’s Creed model of reinventing itself with each new installment, particularly with the Legends spinoffs. Following Arceus, which took players to ancient times, Pokémon Legends ZA is set in the familiar city of Lumiose from Pokémon X and Y. This return to the Paris-inspired setting, known for its Haussmannian architecture and Eiffel Tower stand-in, offers a nostalgic experience for fans. While exploring urban streets for the first time is initially appealing, this initial excitement diminishes as the game progresses.

Urban NPC Glitches and Silent Lumiose: A Stale Open-World Experience

Technical limitations significantly detract from the player experience, particularly in urban areas. Although the presence of pedestrians is a welcome addition, their poorly rendered ankles are distracting, even more so than in Breath of the Wild on Switch. This graphical glitch is apparent regardless of the player’s distance from the NPCs. Furthermore, the silent and motionless behavior of most characters, combined with the absence of voice acting, diminishes immersion. The visually outdated graphics, characterized by flat textures, bare environments, and repetitive architecture, suggest shortcomings in Game Freak’s ability to fully realize open-world environments. While Legends ZA aims to reconnect players with familiar roots in its circular, Paris-like city of Lumiose, the lackluster immersion and uninspired urban gameplay can quickly become tiresome.

Open-World Lumiose: Vibrancy Lost in Repetition and Outdated Graphics

The transition to an open-world format raises questions about whether the trade-offs were worthwhile. While the game offers verticality, Game Freak’s interpretation of Lumiose feels less authentic than its previous iterations. Although teleportation points are available, they lack originality. The art style in Pokémon Legends ZA makes Lumiose feel artificial; buildings, streets, and even plants appear copied and pasted. The setting relies on bland, repetitive structures adorned with blue or red lights, creating the impression of a cheap, cardboard-cutout town. Even detailed interior rooms cannot compensate for the overall lack of vibrancy. Despite these significant drawbacks, Legends ZA introduces some innovative features that offer a glimmer of hope. In summary, Legends ZA’s Paris-inspired Lumiose falls short due to its outdated graphics, lack of immersion, repetitive environments, uninspired gameplay, and tedious level design.

Enthralling Nighttime Battles and Real-Time Combat Enhancements in Pokémon Game

However, the game’s day-night cycle enhances the experience, and the introduction of Royal ZA, a nighttime tournament that transforms the city into a battleground, adds excitement. During the day, players engage in Pokémon hunting, quests, and story progression. At night, the Royal ZA event features trainer battles where players can climb the ranks from Z to A. Held in different locations each night, these battles incorporate surprise attack phases. While the stealth elements are simplistic, reminiscent of older games, the shift to real-time combat marks a significant improvement. This new system emphasizes timing, positioning, and evasion, alongside type matchups and stats. The return of Mega Evolutions from Pokémon X and Y on the 3DS further invigorates battles. The real-time combat system, in particular, shows promise, offering a more dynamic and engaging battle experience.

New Dynamic Battles and Open-World Potential in Pokémon Legends ZA

The new, more dynamic battle system demands careful attention, even from experienced players. With close-quarters combat, long-range attacks, effect zones, reload times, and support abilities, battles offer depth without becoming overly complex. Although confined spaces can lead to chaotic situations, the new style is generally thrilling and enhances the gameplay. Despite its shortcomings, Pokémon Legends ZA introduces some promising ideas. For players to fully embrace this evolution, Game Freak needs to upgrade its tools and graphics engine and refine its approach to creating engaging open-world environments. While this represents a step in a new direction, further improvements are necessary to fully capitalize on Pokémon’s potential.

In Case You Missed It

If you’re eager to stay updated on the latest gaming news, you’re in luck! First up, Marcus Thompson just published an insightful analysis titled “Beloved Xbox Exclusive Set to Leave Game Pass,” which delves into the upcoming departure of several popular titles from Microsoft’s subscription service, including the highly acclaimed Stalker 2: Heart of Chernobyl. Head over here Beloved Xbox Exclusive Set to Leave Game Pass to explore what this means for gaming exclusivity across platforms. Next, football fans might be excited to hear that Jonathan Dubinski has a new piece out called “EA Sports FC 27 May Feature Open World Mode.” Published just last week on November 3rd, it dives into EA Sports’ ambitious plans to introduce an open-world experience to FIFA Ultimate Team (FUT) Champions Mode in their upcoming FC 27. Imagine navigating a cityscape reminiscent of NBA 2K as you engage in high-stakes football action – it’s set to revolutionize your gaming experience! Don’t miss out on this exciting insight; click here to explore the future of football gaming: EA Sports FC 27 May Feature Open World Mode. And speaking of immersive gaming experiences, our fellow enthusiast Bruno Pferd has just published a piece on the latest buzz in Red Dead Redemption 2 mods. In ‘Red Dead Redemption 2 Welcomes a Newly Anticipated Free Mod Fans Have Dreamed Of’ (out now), you’ll find that banks are no longer just pretty facades thanks to Triplexdemn’s ‘Banks of the West’ mod, available for free on Nexus Mods. Head over to Bruno’s post at Red Dead Redemption 2 Welcomes a Newly Anticipated Free Mod Fans Have Dreamed Of to explore this exciting new addition to the game.

Have any thoughts?

Share your reaction or leave a quick response — we’d love to hear what you think!

You may also like