Flying Islands Copied from Zelda? Former Employee Reveals Chaotic Development of Crimson Desert

Recommended products

This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn a commission from purchases made through these links.

Despite achieving commercial success with two million copies sold in its first 24 hours, Crimson Desert has been plagued by narrative criticisms. Now, a former Pearl Abyss developer has publicly alleged that the game’s storyline was a last-minute decision, the product of a conflict-ridden and problematic creative process. This ex-employee’s claims address player questions about the noticeable absence of Crimson Desert references within the game itself and the lack of a narrative trailer prior to its release. According to the developer, these issues stem from significant plan alterations late in production. The original, scrapped plot reportedly focused on a young king, robbed of his throne, who would join the Greymane mercenary group to reclaim his power. This involved conquering territories, fueled by a unique currency derived from minerals sourced directly from the Crimson Desert region. The narrative was to culminate in a betrayal by one of the king’s trusted prime ministers, who would seize the throne, triggering the final confrontation.

Cast changes also occurred. Ervin, for example, was initially conceived as the king’s male personal bodyguard. The ex-employee attributes these abandoned plans to internal power struggles within Pearl Abyss, claiming that management blindly follows trends and often incorporates features and ideas from other games into Crimson Desert. The developer specifically cited an instance where a colleague possessed limited knowledge of Kratos’s arc in God of War. They also recounted another dev describing the mixed reviews as “bittersweet,” because they echoed the team’s own worries that the game felt disjointed. The former Pearl Abyss employee alleges that during development, a significant emphasis was placed on mimicking successful titles like The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, even at the expense of original story elements, prioritizing flashy graphics instead. Adding to the sense of disjointedness, flying islands were reportedly added to the game map simply to capitalize on the success of that mechanic in The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, with little regard for the narrative.

Upside-Down Pyramid Culture Allegedly Drives Aesthetic Prioritization in Crimson Desert’s Development and Metacritic Slump

A current Pearl Abyss developer corroborated aspects of this account, describing the studio’s work culture as an “upside-down pyramid” where leaders favor agreement over constructive criticism. This developer, a Crimson Desert veteran, believes many colleagues silently recognized the game’s issues but feared isolation if they spoke out. This source also confirmed the original plotline involving King Macduff and Ervin’s initial role, as well as the director’s dismissal. The former employee believes these factors contributed to Crimson Desert’s lukewarm reception, especially in Korea. The source believes it was practically destined to flop, given the tricky controls and harsh reviews. Following a middling Metacritic score, Pearl Abyss’s stock plummeted. The ex-employee also stated that a director was forced to resign, and a new general manager, with a purely artistic background, took over, which upended the project. From that point forward, decisions were driven by aesthetics and market trends, lacking narrative coherence. As of now, Pearl Abyss has not officially commented on these allegations.

In Case You Missed It

In our ongoing quest to bring you the latest insights into the gaming world, we’re thrilled to direct your attention to three recent articles that cater to different aspects of your gaming interests. Ahmed Hassan’s review of “Monster Hunter Stories 3”, published on March 21st, dives deep into Capcom’s evolution with the series, praising its dynamic combat system and captivating narrative within a JRPG framework, while also exploring how Monster Hunter has upped its game in terms of graphics, design, soundtrack, and more Monster Hunter Stories 3 Review: Capcom’s Strong Evolution. Next up, Jonathan Dubinski took a deep dive into Pearl Abyss’ “Crimson Desert”, comparing its console adaptability across various platforms in his insightful piece published on the same day. His analysis highlights the superiority of the PS5 Pro in handling Ray Tracing, setting it apart from its competitors and offering gamers an unparalleled visual experience PS5 Pro is the Only One to Handle Ray Tracing in Crimson Desert. Finally, stick around for some promising news from Pearl Abyss that’s worth your attention. Ahmed Hassan’s latest piece, ‘Pearl Abyss Promises to Fix Crimson Desert’s Controls’, published on March 21st, delves into the developer’s plans to improve the game’s control system following player complaints about complexity and latency issues, offering hope for a more enjoyable gaming experience Pearl Abyss Promises to Fix Crimson Desert’s Controls. So, whether you’re eager to explore captivating narratives, impressive visuals, or improved gameplay mechanics, we’ve got you covered with these insightful articles.