“Marvel Succeeds Where DC and Superman Failed: A Critical Review of ‘The Fantastic Four'”

“Marvel’s Fresh Take on The Fantastic Four: A Cinematic Triumph Under Matt Shakman’s Guidance”

Released in late July, just 15 days after a divisive Superman film, The First Steps of The Fantastic Four marks the 37th installment in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). This summer blockbuster arrived with significant expectations for Marvel Studios, aiming to revitalize a franchise that has recently experienced a slowdown. Tasked with both charting a new course for the MCU and erasing the memory of lackluster early 2000s and 2015 adaptations, cast members Pedro Pascal, Vanessa Kirby, Joseph Quinn, and Ebon Moss-Bachrach successfully meet these challenges. Director Matt Shakman, recognized as one of Marvel Studios’ premier hires in recent years, is largely credited with The Fantastic Four’s success. With two decades of experience in television directing, Shakman’s extensive credits include acclaimed series such as Succession, Mad Men, Six Feet Under, The Boys, House M.D., Fargo, and Philly, for which he also served as a producer. He is particularly known for his work on WandaVision, the most successful MCU television series to date.

Fast-Paced Reimagining: Marvel’s Established Fantastic Four in a Cinematic Kirby-Homage World

This Fantastic Four film takes a fresh approach by boldly sidestepping the traditional origin story. Instead, it immerses viewers directly into a world where the Fantastic Four are already established, known, and respected heroes. The narrative begins four years after the astronauts acquired their powers, now serving as the guardians of Earth-828—an alternate reality similar to the main MCU, with a clear homage to Jack Kirby. This strategic decision introduces established heroes rather than new ones and allows for rapid world-building, quickly establishing the team’s public presence while avoiding lengthy explanatory scenes. The film efficiently recounts past events and the acquisition of their powers through a concise, well-crafted montage lasting approximately ten minutes. This approach evokes comparisons to the animated film The Incredibles, particularly in its fast pace and character introductions. The appearance of Mole Man (or Man-Thing) further brings to mind Demolisher from the comics. Interestingly, these two works now seem to share a cinematic connection, almost as if one reflects the other. This parallel is noteworthy, given that The Incredibles was heavily inspired by the Fantastic Four comic series.

A key strength of the film lies in its complete embrace of the 1960s aesthetic, moving beyond a mere setting to fully embody the decade’s spirit. The movie feels like stepping into a “groovy sci-fi sitcom” from that era, presenting a world technologically advanced yet imbued with the utopian optimism prevalent in 1960s thought. This vision manifests through elements like flying cars, futuristic gadgets, the sleek architecture of the Baxter Building, and a reimagined Times Square, collectively forming a cohesive and visually consistent portrayal of 1960s America where progress excites more than it threatens. Marvel Studios further enhanced this immersion by constructing numerous physical sets on location. This tangible approach allows viewers to almost touch the various rooms in the Baxter Building, feel the FantastiCar under their fingertips, and even spot a hidden Easter egg in the UN conference room. Each environment is meticulously crafted, elevating every scene’s impact. This retro-futuristic vibe effectively transports audiences to a 1960s universe while the film consciously remains separate from other MCU productions.

“Authentic Family Dynamics in Marvel’s Fantastic Four – A Study of Character Chemistry and Emotional Depth”

Director Matt Shakman chose to center The Fantastic Four on a deeply human and timeless theme: family. The film immediately adopts a family-centric perspective, fostering an immediate connection with Reed, Sue, Johnny, and Ben. Viewers witness not only their emotional bonds but also their routines, squabbles, and vulnerabilities—their essential realness. This focus on authentic group dynamics is a standout feature, an area where many superhero adaptations often falter, and it is achieved through astute writing and precise casting. The characters exhibit natural chemistry: Ben, Johnny, and Sue engage in playful banter, revealing their clear affection, while Reed balances intellectual brilliance with emotional sensitivity. These portrayals make the characters feel less like archetypal superheroes and more like a genuine familial unit, complete with warmth, disagreements, doubts, and unbreakable bonds. The natural chemistry among these four actors creates an impression of an authentic family unfolding on screen. The film carefully paces key scenes and delivers impactful dialogue during dramatic moments, grounding the narrative in real-life relationships rather than solely cosmic stakes. A subtle cameo by actors from the 1994 film also serves as a direct nod to the franchise’s history.

Exploring Universal Family Tensions in Marvel’s Fantastic Four – A Closer Look at Reed and Sue’s Heartfelt Struggles

Beyond its adventurous tone suggested by trailers, the movie delves into heartfelt personal struggles. A notable example is the familial drama between Reed Richards and Sue Storm following the birth of their son, Franklin. This unexpected narrative twist proves to be both powerful and touching, resonating deeply with many viewers, particularly parents. While the origins of their disagreements are unique to the film’s universe, the human emotion that emerges feels profoundly universal. The film’s expertly crafted tense moments underscore that even superheroes face vulnerability in personal relationships. This aspect contributes significantly to the movie’s power, allowing it to transcend action-packed thrills and deliver a moving exploration of personal struggles and emotions. Although some scenes shown in previews were not included in the final cut, these decisions appear to serve pacing, maintaining the film’s overall balance and impact without compromising its core message or character dynamics.

Marvel’s Fantastic Four: Character-Driven Blockbuster with Emotional Depth and Nuanced Antagonists

Shakman’s storytelling excels in character development and world-building, evident in the thoughtful screenwriting and tension construction. Despite a concise 1-hour and 55-minute runtime, the film maintains a consistent pace, giving detailed attention to each character. While Reed Richards and Sue Storm captivate as a couple, Ben Grimm and Johnny Storm also receive compelling portrayals. Ben’s emotional depth is particularly noteworthy, offering a rarely seen layer in superhero narratives. Johnny, in particular, transcends typical stereotypes, presenting a more sensitive and developed character crucial to the story, departing from the usual reckless archetype and adding a refreshing dimension to the film’s overall appeal. Beyond the heroes, The Fantastic Four also dedicates significant attention to its antagonists. Shalla-Bal, the chilling female counterpart of the Silver Surfer, stands out; she is not merely a superficial update but a character directly from the comics, seamlessly integrated into the film’s narrative. This commitment to both heroes and villains results in a visually impressive film with a nuanced script that allows every character to feel central to the blockbuster adventure.

Galactus’ Intimidating Presence and Giacchino’s Epic Score Enhance Marvel’s Fantastic Four

Galactus, too, is hailed as a major success in character design. Ralph Ineson’s deep, eerie voice acting is pivotal, but his onscreen portrayal truly captivates. Depicted as a colossal figure of metal and mismatched parts, Galactus commands an intimidating presence. His overwhelming scale, massive size, and the silent cosmic threat he embodies position him as a worthy successor to Thanos within this new phase of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Galactus is not simply a destructive force but an embodiment of intense cosmic peril, elevating the stakes and establishing a new benchmark for antagonists. Michael Giacchino’s original score for The Fantastic Four is a standout element. His ability to craft a powerful and memorable theme ensures it resonates long after the credits. Every scene, from epic action sequences to heartfelt moments, is enhanced by perfectly timed musical cues that align seamlessly with the emotion and narrative. Giacchino skillfully employs silence and drama, allowing moments to breathe and enriching the film’s storytelling through his compositions. Critics have lauded the score, awarding it an 8.5/10.

“Marvel’s Fantastic Four Soars with Stunning Universe and Humanity-Focused Storytelling”

Ultimately, Marvel’s latest summer blockbuster, The First Steps of The Fantastic Four, excels where its recent competitor, the Superman film, faltered—by offering a rich, coherent, and visually stunning universe without losing sight of the narrative, a clear contrast to Superman’s struggles with world-building and storytelling despite its lauded color palette. The film’s retro-futuristic aesthetic and emphasis on the humanity of its superheroes contribute significantly to its success. Bolstered by a talented cast, skilled direction from Matt Shakman, and Michael Giacchino’s unforgettable score, The Fantastic Four delivers a compelling and revitalizing entry for the MCU.

About the Author

Carlos Mendoza

Author

Author's posts